NCAA Championship History (2-7) (Four appearances)
2012
First Round: No. 1 South Carolina 7 No. 4 Manhattan 0
Consolation Round: No. 3 Coastal Carolina 11 No. 4 Manhattan 1
2011
First Round: No. 1 Florida 17 No. 4 Manhattan 3
Consolation Round: No. 3 Jacksonville 5 No. 4 Manhattan 4
2006
First Round: No. 4 Manhattan 4 No. 1 Nebraska 1
Winners Bracket Final: No. 2 Miami 8 No. 4 Manhattan 2
Elimination Game: No. 4 Manhattan 6 No. 3 San Francisco 4
Regional Final: No. 2 Miami 10 No. 4 Manhattan 4  
1957
District Two Semifinal: Penn State 2 Manhattan 1

MAAC Championship History (21-23) (14 appearances)
2019 - #5 seed (2-2)
#5 Manhattan 6 #4 Marist 2
#5 Manhattan 5 #1 Canisius 3
#1 QU 11 #5 Manhattan 6
#3 Fairfield 11 #5 Manhattan 5

2017 - #5 seed (0-2)
#6 Rider 4 - #6 Manhattan 3
#4 Iona 5 - #5 Manhattan 1

2016 - #6 seed (2-2)
#6 Manhattan 12-  #3 Monmouth 8
#1 Fairfield 5 - #6 Manhattan 2
#6 Manhattan 8 - #3 Monmouth 1
#2 Siena 15 - #4 Manhattan 4

2014 - #6 seed (0-2)
#3 Fairfield 3 - #6 Manhattan 2
#5 Monmouth 8 - #6 Manhattan 7 (15)

2012 - #1 seed (4-1)
#4 Rider 6 - #1 Manhattan 4
#1 Manhattan 1 - #3 Fairfield 0
#1 Manhattan 6 - #4 Rider 5
#1 Manhattan 5 - #2 Canisius 4 (10)
#1 Manhattan 3 - #2 Canisius 2 (11)

2011 - #1 seed (3-0)
#1 Manhattan 3 - #4 Canisius 2
#1 Manhattan 8 - #3 Siena 7
#1 Manhattan 5 - #3 Siena 1

2010 - #4 seed (1-2)
#1 Canisius 7 - #4 Manhattan 5
#4 Manhattan 6 - #2 Marist 5
#1 Canisius 6 - #4 Manhattan 5

2009 - #1 seed (1-2)
#1 Manhattan 2 - #4 Rider 1
#3 Marist 4 - #1 Manhattan 3 (11)
#2 Canisius 3 - #1 Manhattan 2

2008 - #2 seed (0-2)
#3 Siena 24 - #2 Manhattan 3
#1 Canisius 16 - #2 Manhattan 7

2007 - #2 seed (2-2)
#2 Manhattan 6 - #3 Marist 2
#1 LeMoyne 2 - #2 Manhattan 1
#2 Manhattan 3 - #3 Marist 2
#1 LeMoyne 9 - #2 Manhattan 7

2006 - #1 seed (3-0)
#2 Manhattan 5 - #3 Rider 0
#2 Manhattan 3 - #1 LeMoyne 1
#2 Manhattan 7 - #1 LeMoyne 1

2005 - #3 seed (0-2)
#2 Siena 5 - #3 Manhattan 0
#4 Niagara 3 - #3 Manhattan 0

2004 - #3 seed (2-2)
#3 Manhattan 7 - #2 Niagara 2
#1 LeMoyne 12 - #3 Manhattan 5
#3 Manhattan 12 - #2 Niagara 7
#1 LeMoyne 6 - #3 Manhattan 4

2003 - #1 seed (1-2)
#1 LeMoyne 12 - #4 Manhattan 0
#4 Manhattan 3 - #3 Niagara 2
#2 Marist 2 - #4 Manhattan 1

Won The Title (3) – 2012, 2011, 2006
Finished Second (2) – 2007, 2004
Took Third (4) – 2019, 2010, 2009, 2003
Fourth (2) – 2008, 2005
Sixth (2) – 2014, 2017

Manhattan Against ...
Record vs. FFD: 1-3
Record vs. Siena: 2-3
Record vs. MU: 2-1
Record vs. Canisius: 4-4
Record vs. Marist: 4-2
Record vs. Niagara: 3-1
Record vs. Rider: 3-2
Record vs. LeMoyne: 2-5
Record vs. Iona: 0-1
Record vs. QU: 0-1

Seed Record
As a #1 seed (3): 8-3 – ’12, ’11, ’09 | Won Title in 2012/2011
As a #2 seed (3): 5-4 – ’08, ’07, ’06 | Won Title in 2006
As a #3 seed (2): 2-4  - ’05, ‘04
As a #4 seed (2): 2-4 – ’10, ‘03
As a #5 seed (2): 2-4 – ’19, ‘17
As a #6 seed (2): 2-4 – ’16, ‘14